tutorials

Custom Comments vs Random Comments: Which Should You Order in 2026?

The difference between random, AI and custom comment services, when each one makes sense, and how to write custom comments, answers and live chat messages that read naturally.

SocialBooster Team

SocialBooster Team

Helping brands and creators grow their social media presence with real engagement and professional tools.

November 5, 2026
Custom Comments vs Random Comments: Which Should You Order in 2026?
SocialBooster

Comment services come in a few flavours, and the label on the order form makes a real difference to how the result looks. A post with a handful of comments that fit the content reads very differently from one with a pile of generic emoji. This guide explains the main types, when to use each one, and how to write custom comments that do not give themselves away.

The three main types

Random comments are pre-written, general comments such as "love this", "great post" or a string of emoji. You supply only the link, and the provider picks the text.

AI comments are generated to loosely match the content of the post. They tend to be more varied than random comments and less likely to repeat.

Custom comments are written by you. You supply the link and the text, usually one comment per line, and each line is posted as written.

The same split exists for other text-based services. Quora custom answers, Twitch and Kick custom live chat and similar services all work on the same principle: you write it, the service posts it.

When random comments are fine

Random comments are the cheapest and fastest. They make sense when:

  • The post is visual, such as a photo or short video, where short reactions look natural.
  • You want a small number of comments to break the "zero comments" first impression.
  • The audience is broad and short reactions are normal for that kind of content.

They work less well on long captions, educational posts or anything where people would naturally reply with something specific. A detailed tutorial with comments that only say "nice" looks odd.

When custom comments are worth it

Custom comments cost more and take a few minutes to write, but they are almost always the better choice when:

  • The post asks a question and you want answers that actually respond to it.
  • The content is niche, technical or educational.
  • You are launching a product and want comments that reference it naturally.
  • You are running live chat on a stream and want messages that fit the game or topic.

The difference is credibility. Real visitors read comments. Comments that fit the post make the whole thing look like a genuine conversation they could join.

How to write custom comments that read naturally

This is where most people go wrong. Custom comments only help if they sound like real people.

Vary length and tone

Real comment sections are messy. Some comments are one word, some are a sentence, a few are longer. Mix it up.

Respond to the content

Reference something specific in the post. If it is a recipe, ask about a substitution. If it is a workout, mention which move looked hardest.

Ask questions

Questions invite replies, both from you and from real visitors. "Does this work on older phones too?" starts a thread. "Great video" does not.

Avoid over-the-top praise

"This is the best content on the entire platform, you are a genius" reads as fake immediately. Moderate, specific comments are more convincing.

Do not repeat yourself

If you are ordering twenty comments, write twenty genuinely different lines. Duplicates are the fastest way to make a comment section look manufactured.

A quick example

For a short video showing a home coffee setup, compare these:

Random style: "Nice", "Love it", "🔥🔥", "Amazing".

Custom style: "What grinder is that?", "The pour at the end is so satisfying", "I need to stop buying coffee out and just do this", "How long did it take to get the milk texture right?"

The second set gives real visitors something to read, and gives you easy questions to reply to.

Reply to them

Whichever type you order, reply to a few comments. A creator responding in their own comment section makes the conversation feel alive, encourages real viewers to join in and shows platforms that the post is generating discussion.

What comment services do not do

Ordered comments are social proof. They make a post look discussed. They do not bring new followers on their own, and they do not make weak content better. Buying engagement is also against most platforms' terms and carries some risk, so keep volume modest and believable for your account size.

Never write comments that make false claims, impersonate real people or mislead buyers about a product. Keep it to the kind of thing a real viewer could plausibly say.

Ordering

All comment types need only a public post link. Custom services also need your text, one item per line, so proofread before you submit because each line is posted as written. You can compare comment, answer and live chat options across platforms on the services page, and our caption writer tool can help if you are stuck for phrasing ideas.

The short answer

Use random comments for quick, visual posts where short reactions are normal. Use custom comments whenever the post invites a specific response, or whenever credibility matters. Write them like real people would, vary them and reply to them. A few good comments do more than a pile of generic ones.

Ready to grow your social media?

Put these strategies into action with SocialBooster. Real engagement across every major platform — delivery starts in minutes.

Instant delivery100% safeRefund guarantee

Free Social Media Tools

16 free tools to level up your social media game — no signup required.

Ready to put this into action?

Grow your social media presence with SocialBooster. Fast delivery, real engagement.